Waterfront's Dieppe monument desecrated

scotto

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2004
6,985
218
63
The Beach Strip
#1
Posted with full permission from the hamilton Spectator.
________________________

Bill Dunphy
The Hamilton Spectator
(Aug 13, 2007)
A week before ceremonies honouring the bloody sacrifices made at Dieppe by Hamilton's most storied regiment, someone has vandalized their waterfront monument.

"I was devastated," said Dieppe veteran and Royal Hamilton Light Infantry member Jack McFarland after discovering the vandalism during a pre-ceremony sweep to ensure things were shipshape.

They weren't.

Vandals had spray-painted both sides of a city sign pointing to the concrete and granite monument. Worse, someone had attacked the granite cairn at the centre of the monument and pried off a bronze replica of the Riley's collar badge that adorned the north face.

"I think someone went at it with a crowbar," said James Forsyth, the honorary colonel of the regiment.

"It would have been a real undertaking to get it off."

The bronze piece is about 30 centimetres square and features the regiment's bugle suspended from the King's crown by two loops of knotted rope.

McFarland -- a retired Hamilton police officer -- speculated the piece may have been pried off the monument by thieves hoping to sell it for its scrap value.

Regardless of the motive, McFarland was deeply offended by the vandalism.

"I was mad. To think that anyone would do this to this war monument ... we waited 30 years to get this."

The monument, a grand sweep of tumbled stone with walls sheltering the stone cairn, all of it facing the lake and overlooked by a quintet of flags, cost $350,000 and was unveiled four years ago on the 61st anniversary of the Dieppe raid. During that disastrous landing in France, the Royal Hamilton Light Infantry was virtually destroyed -- 82 per cent of the 582 men who went ashore Aug., 19, 1942, were killed, wounded or taken prisoner.

McFarland himself was shot and captured and spent two and half years in a prison camp. He views the monument as something sacred. After discovering the vandalism Thursday, McFarland called Forsyth and city parks staff and was delighted with the city's response -- the graffiti was removed by Saturday. But the plaque is a different story.

"I guess there's no way it will be replaced by the ceremony. It's a real shame," McFarland said as he surveyed the now blank northern face of the cairn.

Forsyth is trying to get the piece replaced.

"Our big concern is whether the manufacturer still has the mould -- if he does, then we can get it reproduced and remounted."

This year's ceremony will go ahead as planned Sunday on the raid's anniversary, despite the damaged monument.

"We have a parade and a short memorial service. The regimental band will be there. The city puts out 200 chairs, but there's usually people left standing," he said.

"(This vandalism) is a shame. The veterans are very pleased with the monument, the city did a first-class job. To them it's sacred. If a war memorial isn't sacred, what is?"

bdunphy@thespec.com

905-526-3262

Dieppe at a glance

* The raid took place on Aug. 19, 1942, and involved more than 6,000 infantry, over 5,O00 of them from Canada. It was the first major amphibious assault on German-held European territory. * The raid targeted three towns: Dieppe, Puys and Pourville. The Royal Hamilton Light Infantry was part of the centre assault on the pebbled beaches of Dieppe itself. * The raid was badly planned and poorly co-ordinated: the invaders sustained heavy losses and were driven back by a much smaller German force. Of the nearly 6,100 men who participated, 1,027 were killed (including 907 Canadians) and 2,340 were captured. * Nearly 600 members of the Royal Hamilton Light Infantry took part in the Dieppe raid, 179 were killed during the raid, 301 were wounded, 174 were taken prisoner. * Three Victoria Crosses were awarded to Allied participants for their bravery during the raid, including one to Captain John Weir Foote of Royal Hamilton Light Infantry. * The German forces recorded 311 dead, wounded or missing in the raid.

Photo- Daniel Hayduk, the Hamilton Spectator
Veteran Jack McFarland fought at Dieppe. More than 5,000 Canadians took part and 907 of them were killed.
 

scotto

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2004
6,985
218
63
The Beach Strip
#2
I stopped by today and had a look at the monument. I think someone removed the bronze replica for a trophy and not scrap, my opinion only. If anyone knows where it is please return it, drop it off at 924 beach Blvd no questions asked. Attached is a picture of the section of the monument where the replica was once placed and another from the opposite side showing, from what I have been told, an exact copy.
(Edit; as you can see from the next post, it is not an exact copy, refer to the Spec picture.)
 

scotto

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2004
6,985
218
63
The Beach Strip
#3
Stolen plaque won't fetch much

Posted with full permission from the Hamilton Spectator.
_________________________________________
Dana Brown
The Hamilton Spectator
(Aug 14, 2007)
If the vandals who stole the bronze Royal Hamilton Light Infantry plaque from the face of that storied regiment's Dieppe memorial thought they were going to cash in big by selling it for scrap, they'd better think again.

Although the piece may cost the city as much as $800 to $1,000 to replace if a new one has to be made, the 25-centimetre moulded bronze crown and bugle (the regiment's insignia) is only worth a tiny fraction of that as scrap.

"(Scrap) bronze is worth about $15 for 10 pounds," says Fred Posner, a Hamilton scrap metals dealer, "but to me it makes no sense. If you're looking to steal scrap, why would you do that other stuff?" he asked, referring to the graffiti spray painted on both sides of a city sign for the memorial park.

The graffiti was cleaned up within a day of the city being notified, but it will likely take much longer to replace the bronze if it doesn't turn up. Stephanie Clemance of Matthews Canada, the company that made the plaque, said staff began searching records yesterday at their Milton offices and in Pittsburgh, Pa., where it was made, searching for the original plans and mould.

"This isn't going to happen in time for the ceremony," said monument designer Arnis Budrevics, saying that whoever took it was "a scoundrel who didn't understand the significance of the monument."

Posner said he hasn't seen anything like the missing plaque and added that "if someone was to bring it in here, if it came by itself, it would be like lightning striking us ... "

Photo Courtesy of Arnis Budrevics
This is the actual bronze plaque vandals pried off the Dieppe monument.
 

scotto

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2004
6,985
218
63
The Beach Strip
#4
A cowardly act

Robert Howard
The Hamilton Spectator
(Aug 14, 2007)
It's lucky for the creep who recently defaced the monument at Hamilton's Dieppe Memorial Park that he wasn't spotted by a veteran of the disastrous Second World War landing.

The survivors of the 1942 raid by the Royal Hamilton Light Infantry are aged now, but we suspect any one of them would go down fighting to protect what they -- as we -- see as sacred ground. An RHLI vet would not -- could not -- turn a blind eye to wilful desecration.

This is a monument to courage and sacrifice on a scale that most of us do not know and will never truly comprehend. The "Rileys" lost 197 men that August day and five other area men in other units also died in the raid. Hundreds more were wounded or taken prisoner. We should never look past disrespect for the men and women who sacrificed for their country and for the freedoms that we of later generations enjoy.

The city can look at whether better lighting or other measures can help protect this and other memorials. The monument will be repaired and most citizens will share veterans' disgust at a cheap and cowardly act.

And let's never turn a blind eye. If you see vandalism -- anywhere -- call 911. It's a crime -- in every sense.

Editorials are written by members of the editorial board. They represent the position of the newspaper, not necessarily the individual author.
 

scotto

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2004
6,985
218
63
The Beach Strip
#5
City will fix Dieppe monument

Bill Dunphy
The Hamilton Spectator
(Aug 14, 2007)
Shocked and angered by the vandalizing of the Dieppe monument, Hamiltonians and city officials rallied behind local veterans yesterday, promising to repair the lakefront memorial.

And the repairs go beyond replacing the 25-cm (10-inch) bronze crown-and-bugle patch vandals ripped from the cairn's north face sometime in the past week or two. City officials told veterans yesterday that they expect to pave an adjacent parking lot and repair cracks that have appeared in the concrete wall and foundation of the four-year-old, $420,000 tribute to the sacrifices of the Royal Hamilton Light Infantry.

The cracks have been the subject of discussions between the city and the contractor who built the monument, but the RHLI's honorary colonel, James Forsyth, said he's been told the city is determined to fix things.

"The indication I got from the city is that both the parking lot and the cracks will be taken care of, regardless of who's paying," Forsyth said yesterday.

Toronto landscape architect Arnis Budrevics, who designed the monument, said he got a call about the damage from city staff at 8:30 yesterday morning and was meeting with them.

"The city seems to have it well in hand," said Forsyth gratefully.

Although some readers have called in offering to raise reward money to catch the vandals, while others have pledged funds to pay for a new plaque, Forsyth said that at this point the veterans are not fundraising. A memorial ceremony will be held Sunday marking the 65th anniversary of the battle.

bdunphy@thespec.com

905-526-3262
 

rorush

RIP March 21, 1973 - February 07, 2010
Mar 3, 2004
20
1
0
Beach
#6
graffiti also painted at beachway park

I believe it would have been on night of the august 12th someone spray painted profanity on both slides and numerous other places around the park
 

scotto

Administrator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2004
6,985
218
63
The Beach Strip
#8
New Dieppe plaque will take time

Bill Dunphy
The Hamilton Spectator
(Aug 15, 2007)
It will be at least five or six weeks before a new bronze plaque can be cast to replace the one ripped from the Dieppe monument by vandals earlier this month.

That's the word from Matthews Canada, the local sales office of a Pittsburgh-based company that manufactured the four-year-old monument's many plaques.

"We don't have the original mould, they're only kept for three months," explained Stephanie Clemance of Matthews. "It's three dimensional, so a model has to be created, it has to be approved and then we can cast it."

Clemance confirmed that an order has already been put in for the replacement, which will cost $800 to $1,000.

James Forsyth, honorary colonel of the Royal Hamilton Light Infantry, said Dieppe veterans and regiment members understand the delay, so the missing plaque won't dampen their 65th anniversary memorial service, slated for 11 a.m. Sunday. The monument stands in Dieppe Memorial Park, just south of the Burlington Canal lift bridge.
 
Top Bottom